feelsalike.comSign in
Once Upon a Time in America poster

Movies that feel likeOnce Upon a Time in America (1984)

A former Prohibition-era Jewish gangster returns to the Lower East Side of Manhattan over thirty years later, where he once again must confront the ghosts and regrets of his old life.

If you loved Once Upon a Time in America, the closest films we have are Mean Streets (1973), Carlito's Way (1993) and As Tears Go By (1988). All three share Once Upon a Time in America's contemplative and gritty feel, which is what we rank on before quality.

Seen the big three already? The under-the-radar pick below is Pixote (1980).

🍅 86% Rotten Tomatoes★ 8.3 IMDb ↗TMDB ↗dir. Sergio Leonecontemplativegrittyromantic
8 of 12 streaming nowHBO Max · Amazon Prime Video · Criterion Channel

Can't choose? Answer three questions and get one movie for tonight.

Not on subscription streaming right now. Rent or buy below.

See it on the Mood Map

If Once Upon a Time in America hit the spot, these will too

Mean Streets poster
Mean Streets
1973 · dir. Martin Scorsese
🍅 92%★ 7.1drama · crime

Street-level hoods bound by loyalty and guilt in a New York that owns them

The difference: Small and scrappy where Leone is vast — days, not decades

A small-time hood must choose from among love, friendship and the chance to rise within the mob.

Carlito's Way poster
Carlito's Way
1993 · dir. Brian De Palma
🍅 84%★ 7.9crime · drama · thrillerPrime VideoStarz

An aging criminal haunted by his past tries to outrun the old neighborhood

The difference: Propulsive and streamlined — none of Leone's dreamlike sprawl

Free after years in prison, Carlito Brigante intends to give up his criminal ways, but it's not long before the ex-con is sucked back into the New York City underworld.

As Tears Go By poster
As Tears Go By
1988 · dir. Wong Kar-Wai
🍅 85%★ 7drama · crime · romanceMax

A doomed romance keeps pulling a gangster back toward the life he can't quit

The difference: Compact and neon-soaked where Leone stretches across decades

Mid-level gangster Wah falls in love with his beautiful cousin, but must also continue to protect his volatile partner-in-crime and friend, Fly.

Once Upon a Time in the West poster
Once Upon a Time in the West
1968 · dir. Sergio Leone
🍅 96%★ 8.5drama · western

Leone's other elegy — time, memory and loss stretched to operatic scale

The difference: A western through and through; the city and the mob are gone

As the railroad builders advance unstoppably through the Arizona desert on their way to the sea, Jill arrives in the small town of Flagstone with the intention of starting a new life.

Duck, You Sucker poster
Duck, You Sucker
1971 · dir. Sergio Leone
🍅 92%★ 7.5westernPrime Video

Leone again — two men bound by history, shot with the same mournful grandeur

The difference: A dusty revolution western, far from New York's rackets

At the beginning of the 1913 Mexican Revolution, greedy bandit Juan Miranda and idealist John H. Mallory, an Irish Republican Army explosives expert on the lam from the British, fall in with a band of revolutionaries plotting to strike a national bank. When it turns out that the government has been using the bank as a hiding place for illegally detained political prisoners -- who are freed by the blast -- Miranda becomes a revolutionary hero against his will.

Monster poster
Monster
2003 · dir. Patty Jenkins
🍅 81%★ 7.3crime · drama

Life at the brutal bottom, told with pity rather than judgment

The difference: A raw true-crime character study with no epic sweep at all

In 1989, prostitute Aileen Wuornos befriends and enters a relationship with a young woman named Selby. Determined to straighten out her life, Aileen's limited education lands her back on the corner. She's raped by a trick, who she kills. A string of murder and robbery follows that ultimately leads Aileen to becoming America's first female serial killer.

A Short Film About Killing poster
A Short Film About Killing
1988 · dir. Krzysztof Kieślowski
🍅 91%★ 7.9crime · drama

Contemplative where it counts, gritty underneath

The difference: Lighter on romance

Jacek climbs into the taxi driven by Waldemar, tells him to drive to a remote location, then brutally strangles him, seemingly without motive.

Pixote poster
Pixote
1980 · dir. Héctor Babenco
🍅 94%★ 7.9crime · drama

Contemplative drama, and it commits to that

10-year-old Pixote endures torture, degradation, and corruption at a local youth detention center where two of its members are murdered by policemen who frame Lilica, a 17-year-old trans hustler. Pixote helps Lilica and three other boys escape and they start to make their living by a life of crime which only escalates to more violence and death.

Close-Up poster
Close-Up
1990 · dir. Abbas Kiarostami
🍅 89%★ 8.2crime · drama

Crime built on grit, twice over

This fiction-documentary hybrid uses a sensational real-life event—the arrest of a young man on charges that he fraudulently impersonated the well-known filmmaker Mohsen Makhmalbaf—as the basis for a stunning, multilayered investigation into movies, identity, artistic creation, and existence, in which the real people from the case play themselves.

GoodFellas poster
GoodFellas
1990 · dir. Martin Scorsese
🍅 93%★ 8.7drama · crime

A whole life inside the mob, from streetwise kid to haunted survivor

The difference: Runs on jittery momentum where Leone drifts like memory

The true story of Henry Hill, a half-Irish, half-Sicilian Brooklyn kid who is adopted by neighbourhood gangsters at an early age and climbs the ranks of a Mafia family under the guidance of Jimmy Conway.

Days of Being Wild poster
Days of Being Wild
1990 · dir. Wong Kar-Wai
🍅 91%★ 7.4crime · drama · romanceMax

Both lean on romance more than on drama

The difference: Played as romance first

Yuddy, a Hong Kong playboy known for breaking girls' hearts, tries to find solace and truth after discovering the woman who raised him isn't his mother.

West Side Story poster
West Side Story
1961 · dir. Jerome Robbins
🍅 92%★ 7.6crime · drama · romance

Both rooted in New York City

The difference: Made in the 1960s, in a different era of the craft

In Manhattan’s Upper West Side, rival gangs of Polish-Americans and newly arrived Puerto Ricans clash for control of the neighborhood, even as two young members from opposite sides fall dangerously in love.

In the mood for more contemplative?

all contemplative movies →

The best-reviewed films that share Once Upon a Time in America’s defining feeling.