
Movies that feel likeOnce Upon a Time in America (1984)
If you loved Once Upon a Time in America, the closest films we have are Mean Streets (1973), Carlito's Way (1993) and Duck, You Sucker (1971). All three share Once Upon a Time in America's gritty feel, which is what we rank on before quality.
Seen the big three already? The under-the-radar pick below is As Tears Go By (1988).
Can't choose? Answer three questions and get one movie for tonight.
If Once Upon a Time in America hit the spot, these will too

Street-level hoods bound by loyalty and guilt in a New York that owns them
The difference: Small and scrappy where Leone is vast — days, not decades

An aging criminal haunted by his past tries to outrun the old neighborhood
The difference: Propulsive and streamlined — none of Leone's dreamlike sprawl

Leone again — two men bound by history, shot with the same mournful grandeur
The difference: A dusty revolution western, far from New York's rackets

Sergio Leone directing both, with the same fingerprints on each
The difference: Lighter on stillness

Both are Sergio Leone's work, and they rhyme
The difference: Played as western first

Leone's other elegy — time, memory and loss stretched to operatic scale
The difference: A western through and through; the city and the mob are gone

A doomed romance keeps pulling a gangster back toward the life he can't quit
The difference: Compact and neon-soaked where Leone stretches across decades

Gritty where it counts, romantic underneath
The difference: Leans further into action

Drama built on grit, twice over

Longing and self-invention shading step by step into the unforgivable
The difference: Sunlit and seductive; the underworld here is one man's lies

Both lean on stillness more than on crime

Both rooted in New York City
The difference: 23 years apart, and the 1960s show
The feel of Once Upon a Time in America, by the numbers
- It sits in the top 3% of the 2,190 rated contemplative films we track, by IMDb rating.
- 12 of its 12 closest matches share its gritty streak, which is the thread tying this list together.
How common each of its moods is across everything we track (a full bar is 40% or more):
When is Once Upon a Time in America streaming?
Once Upon a Time in America is streaming now
Included with a subscription on Amazon Prime Video, Amazon Prime Video with Ads.
Context: Across 104 films released since 2025, the median theater-to-digital window is 33 days. Since 2015 across our catalog: 46 days over 670 films. See the full data →
In the mood for more contemplative?
all contemplative movies →The best-reviewed films that share Once Upon a Time in America’s defining feeling.









