feelsalike.com

Movies that feel like Nightmare Alley (2021)

If you loved Nightmare Alley, the closest films we have are Tuner (2026), The Devil All the Time (2020) and Joker: Folie à Deux (2024). All three share Nightmare Alley's gritty and contemplative feel, which is what we rank on before quality. 7 of the 12 picks below are included with a subscription right now on Netflix, HBO Max and Amazon Prime Video and others, checked against today's data.

An ambitious carnival man with a talent for manipulating people with a few well-chosen words hooks up with a female psychologist who is even more dangerous than he is.

🍅 80% Rotten Tomatoes7 IMDb ↗TMDB ↗dir. Guillermo del Torogrittycontemplativetenseplayfulromantic
Stream it:FXNow
See it on the map

When is Nightmare Alley streaming? →

If Nightmare Alley hit the spot, these will too

Tuner poster
Tuner
2026 · dir. Daniel Roher
🍅 94%7.2crime · drama · thriller

One thread runs through both: mentor

The difference: Not nearly as playful as Nightmare Alley

A talented piano tuner's meticulous skills for tuning pianos lead him to discover an unexpected aptitude for cracking safes, turning his life upside down.

Feels alike?
The Devil All the Time poster
The Devil All the Time
2020 · dir. Antonio Campos
🍅 65%7.1crime · drama · thriller

Both keep coming back to the same thing: murder

In Knockemstiff, Ohio and its neighboring backwoods, sinister characters converge around young Arvin Russell as he fights the evil forces that threaten him and his family.

Feels alike?
Joker: Folie à Deux poster
Joker: Folie à Deux
2024 · dir. Todd Phillips
🍅 31%5.2drama · crime · thriller

The same mix in both: grit, then stillness

The difference: Critics were much harder on this one

While struggling with his dual identity, Arthur Fleck not only stumbles upon true love, but also finds the music that's always been inside him.

Feels alike?
Side Effects poster
Side Effects
2013 · dir. Steven Soderbergh
🍅 82%7.1thriller · crime · drama

The same preoccupation in both: murder

A woman turns to prescription medication as a way of handling her anxiety concerning her husband's upcoming release from prison.

Feels alike?
Hyena poster
Hyena
2015 · dir. Gerard Johnson
🍅 78%6.2crime · drama · thriller

Tense crime, and it commits to that

Good policing doesn't necessarily mean doing everything by the book. But as the business of crime in London turns to favour the Albanians and Turks, how does a "good" policeman survive?

Feels alike?
Carlito's Way poster
Carlito's Way
1993 · dir. Brian De Palma
🍅 84%7.9crime · drama · thriller

Drama built on romance, twice over

The difference: Made in the 1990s, in a different era of the craft

Free after years in prison, Carlito Brigante intends to give up his criminal ways, but it's not long before the ex-con is sucked back into the New York City underworld.

Feels alike?
Layer Cake poster
Layer Cake
2004 · dir. Matthew Vaughn
🍅 81%7.2drama · thriller · crime

Thriller with a pulse of grit, in both cases

When a seemingly straight-forward drug deal goes awry, XXXX has to break his die-hard rules and turn up the heat, not only to outwit the old regime and come out on top, but to save his own skin...

Feels alike?
The Traitor poster
The Traitor
2019 · dir. Marco Bellocchio
🍅 86%7.1drama · crime · thriller

Both lean on stillness more than on crime

Palermo, Sicily, 1980. Mafia member Tommaso Buscetta decides to move to Brazil with his family fleeing the constant war between the different clans of the criminal organization. But when, after living several misfortunes, he is forced to return to Italy, he makes a bold decision that will change his life and the destiny of Cosa Nostra forever.

Feels alike?
Emily the Criminal poster
Emily the Criminal
2022 · dir. John Patton Ford
🍅 93%6.7crime · drama · thriller

Tense drama in both cases

Desperate for income, Emily takes a shady gig buying goods with stolen credit cards supplied by a charismatic middleman named Youcef. Seduced by the quick cash and illicit thrills, they hatch a plan to take their business to the next level.

Feels alike?
Holy Spider poster
Holy Spider
2022 · dir. Ali Abbasi
🍅 82%7.3thriller · drama · crime

Gritty thriller in both cases

A journalist descends into the dark underbelly of the Iranian holy city of Mashhad as she investigates the serial killings of sex workers by the so called "Spider Killer", who believes he is cleansing the streets of sinners.

Feels alike?
The Wild Goose Lake poster
The Wild Goose Lake
2019 · dir. Diao Yinan
🍅 91%6.7crime · drama · thriller

Crime built on stillness, twice over

A gangster ends up making a mistake that causes every gun on both sides of the law to point at him. While on the run, he comes across a mysterious woman who might get him out of trouble or make things worse.

Feels alike?
The Next Three Days poster
The Next Three Days
2010 · dir. Paul Haggis
🍅 50%7.3romance · drama · thriller

Romantic drama, and it commits to that

The difference: Sits closer to romance than Nightmare Alley does

Life seems perfect for John Brennan until his wife, Lara, is arrested for a murder she says she didn’t commit. Three years into her sentence, John is struggling to hold his family together, raising their son and teaching at college while he pursues every means available to prove her innocence. With the rejection of their final appeal, Lara becomes suicidal and John decides there is only one possible, bearable solution: to break his wife out of prison.

Feels alike?

In the mood for more gritty?

all gritty movies →

The best-reviewed films that share Nightmare Alley’s defining feeling.