Podcasts that feel like
My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
Exactly Right and iHeartPodcasts · True Crime · 1231 episodes
The show that made true crime comedy a genre. Stay sexy.
If My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark hit the spot, these will too
Ash Kelley & Alaina Urquhart · True Crime
True crime between friends who make the dark survivable
The difference: Younger energy, more research tangents
A hairdresser and an autopsy tech make the macabre feel like girls' night.
Christine Schiefer, Em Schulz · Comedy
Crime and ghosts with cocktail-hour chemistry
The difference: Adds the paranormal half
One believer, one skeptic, ghosts and true crime and boxed wine.
James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whisman · Comedy
Comedy and true crime with the ratio flipped
The difference: More jokes, deeper case files
Comedians tell shocking small-town cases with respect for victims and none for towns.
The Last Podcast Network · True Crime
The heavy-research heavy-laughs institution
The difference: Darker topics, wilder bits
Heavy research and heavier laughs across serial killers, cults, and cryptids.
RedHanded · True Crime
Weekly cases with hosts you trust
The difference: British, more social analysis
Sharp British true crime with wit, rigor, and real empathy.
Normal Gossip · Comedy
The comfort-listen dynamic without the murder
The difference: Gossip stakes, zero bodies
Anonymous everyday gossip retold as delicious serialized drama.
YMH Studios · Comedy
shares that witty, playful feel
Two best friends, zero filter, maximum bear energy.
Headgum / Doughboys Media · Comedy
shares that witty, playful feel
Two comedians review chain restaurants with the seriousness of war reporters.
Matt McCusker & Shane Gillis · Comedy
shares that witty, playful feel
Philly-basement comedy that conquered the world anyway.
Browse the full podcast catalog or see what America is listening to right now.