feelsalike.comSign in
When We First Met poster

Movies that feel likeWhen We First Met (2018)

Using a magical photo booth that sends him back in time, Noah relives the night he met Avery over and over, trying to persuade her to fall for him.

If you loved When We First Met, the closest films we have are The Mermaid (2016), 13 Going on 30 (2004) and The Man from the Future (2011). All three share When We First Met's witty and playful feel, which is what we rank on before quality.

Seen the big three already? The under-the-radar pick below is The Purple Rose of Cairo (1985).

🍅 45% Rotten Tomatoes★ 6.4 IMDb ↗TMDB ↗dir. Ari Sandelwittyplayfulromanticdreamlike
10 of 12 streaming nowHBO Max · Amazon Prime Video · Disney Plus

Can't choose? Answer three questions and get one movie for tonight.

Stream it:Netflix ↗
See it on the Mood Map

When is When We First Met streaming? ↓

If When We First Met hit the spot, these will too

The Mermaid poster
The Mermaid
2016 · dir. Stephen Chow
🍅 95%★ 6.2comedy · fantasy · romance

The same mix in both: wit, then play

The difference: Critics rated this one higher still

When Xuan's real estate project threatens the home of mermaids, Shan is sent to stop him. When they fall in love, he is encouraged to cancel the project. However, he must save them from bigger danger.

13 Going on 30 poster
13 Going on 30
2004 · dir. Gary Winick
🍅 65%★ 6.4comedy · fantasy · romanceParamount+

One thread runs through both: time travel

After total humiliation at her thirteenth birthday party, Jenna Rink wants to just hide until she's thirty. Thanks to some magic wishing dust, Jenna's prayer has been answered. With a knockout body, a fabulous wardrobe, an athlete boyfriend, a dream job, and superstar friends, this can't be a better life. But soon Jenna realizes that adult life isn’t as easy as she hoped for.

The Man from the Future poster
The Man from the Future
2011 · dir. Cláudio Torres
★ 7comedy · fantasy · science fiction

The same preoccupation in both: time travel

The difference: Sits closer to science fiction than When We First Met does

Zero is a brilliant scientist. However, 20 years ago, he was publicly humiliated when he lost Helena, the love of his life. One day, an accidental experience with one of his inventions causes him to travel back in time to 1991. Having taken the opportunity to change history, Zero returns to own time to find totally changed.

While You Were Sleeping poster
While You Were Sleeping
1995 · dir. Jon Turteltaub
🍅 81%★ 6.8romance · comedyDisney+

Both land romance and dream logic at once

The difference: 23 years apart, and the 1990s show

A transit worker pulls commuter Peter off railway tracks after he's mugged, but—while he's in a coma—his family mistakenly thinks she's Peter's fiancée, and she doesn't correct them. Things get more complicated when she falls for his brother, who's not quite sure that she's who she claims to be.

Every Day poster
Every Day
2018 · dir. Michael Sucsy
🍅 65%★ 6.5romance · fantasy

Romance with a pulse of romance, in both cases

The difference: Trades the wit of When We First Met for an angle of its own

16-year old Rhiannon falls in love with a mysterious spirit named “A” that inhabits a different body every day. Feeling an unmatched connection, Rhiannon and “A” work each day to find each other, not knowing what the next day will bring.

The Purple Rose of Cairo poster
The Purple Rose of Cairo
1985 · dir. Woody Allen
🍅 93%★ 7.6fantasy · comedy · romancePrime Video

Both lean on wit more than on comedy

Cecilia is a waitress in New Jersey, living a dreary life during the Great Depression. Her only escape from her mundane reality is the movie theatre. After losing her job, Cecilia goes to see 'The Purple Rose of Cairo' in hopes of raising her spirits, where she watches dashing archaeologist Tom Baxter time and again.

The Invention of Lying poster
The Invention of Lying
2009 · dir. Ricky Gervais
🍅 56%★ 6.4comedy · fantasy · romance

Playful fantasy in both cases

Set in a world where the concept of lying doesn't exist, a loser changes his lot when he invents lying and uses it to get ahead.

Just My Luck poster
Just My Luck
2006 · dir. Donald Petrie
🍅 14%★ 5.5comedy · fantasy · romancePrime Video

Dreamlike comedy, and it commits to that

Manhattanite Ashley is known to many as the luckiest woman around. After a chance encounter with a down-and-out young man, however, she realizes that she's swapped her fortune for his.

Practical Magic poster
Practical Magic
1998 · dir. Griffin Dunne
🍅 31%★ 6.4romance · fantasy · comedyMax

Romance built on wit, twice over

Sally and Gillian Owens, born into a magical family, have mostly avoided witchcraft themselves. But when Gillian's vicious boyfriend, Jimmy Angelov, dies unexpectedly, the Owens sisters give themselves a crash course in hard magic. With policeman Gary Hallet growing suspicious, the girls struggle to resurrect Angelov -- and unwittingly inject his corpse with an evil spirit that threatens to end their family line.

Bewitched poster
Bewitched
2005 · dir. Nora Ephron
🍅 23%★ 4.9comedy · fantasy · romance

Fantasy with a pulse of play, in both cases

Thinking he can overshadow an unknown actress in the part, an egocentric actor unknowingly gets a witch cast in an upcoming television remake of the classic show "Bewitched".

Monster-in-Law poster
Monster-in-Law
2005 · dir. Robert Luketic
🍅 19%★ 5.6romance · comedyMax

Romantic comedy in both cases

Office temp Charlotte Cantilini thinks she's found Mr. Right when she starts dating gorgeous surgeon Dr. Kevin Fields. But there's a problem standing in the way of everlasting bliss: Kevin's overbearing and controlling mother, Viola. Fearing she'll lose her son's affections forever, Viola decides to break up the happy couple by becoming the world's worst mother-in-law.

Shallow Hal poster
Shallow Hal
2001 · dir. Bobby Farrelly
🍅 49%★ 6comedy · fantasy · romance

Both lean on dream logic more than on romance

After taking his dying father's advice, Hal dates only the embodiments of female physical perfection. But that all changes after Hal has an unexpected run-in with self-help guru Tony Robbins. Intrigued by Hal's shallowness, Robbins hypnotizes him into seeing the beauty that exists even in the least physically appealing women. Hal soon falls for Rosemary, but he doesn't realize that his gorgeous girlfriend is actually a 300-pound-not-so-hottie.

The feel of When We First Met, by the numbers

  • 12 of its 12 closest matches share its romantic streak, which is the thread tying this list together.

How common each of its moods is across everything we track (a full bar is 40% or more):

witty30.2%
playful31.2%

When is When We First Met streaming?

CONFIRMED

When We First Met is streaming now

Included with a subscription on Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads.

Digital release (rent/buy)February 9, 2018
Streaming onNetflix, Netflix Standard with Ads

Context: Across 104 films released since 2025, the median theater-to-digital window is 33 days. Since 2015 across our catalog: 46 days over 670 films. See the full data →

In the mood for more witty?

all witty movies →

The best-reviewed films that share When We First Met’s defining feeling.