feelsalike.comSign in
Urban Legend poster

Movies that feel likeUrban Legend (1998)

A college campus is plagued by a vicious serial killer murdering students in ways that correspond to various urban legends.

If you loved Urban Legend, the closest films we have are I See You (2019), Noroi: The Curse (2005) and Immaculate (2024). All three share Urban Legend's twisty and dread feel, which is what we rank on before quality.

Seen the big three already? The under-the-radar pick below is Finders Keepers (2014).

πŸ… 32% Rotten Tomatoesβ˜… 5.6 IMDb β†—TMDB β†—dir. Jamie Blankstwistydreadunsettlingtense
10 of 12 streaming nowNetflix Β· Amazon Prime Video Β· Peacock Premium

Can't choose? Answer three questions and get one movie for tonight.

Not on subscription streaming right now. Rent or buy below.

See it on the Mood Map

If Urban Legend hit the spot, these will too

I See You poster
I See You
2019 Β· dir. Adam Randall
πŸ… 73%β˜… 6.8horror Β· thriller Β· mysteryRent or buy

The same two preoccupations: twist, and murder

The difference: Critics rated this one higher still

When a 12-year-old boy goes missing at a local park, a detective investigates the case to help the boy's family find answers.

Noroi: The Curse poster
Noroi: The Curse
2005 Β· dir. Koji Shiraishi
β˜… 6.8horror Β· mystery Β· thrillerRent or buy

Twisty and dread-soaked in the same breath

A documentary filmmaker explores seemingly unrelated paranormal incidents connected by the legend of an ancient demon.

Immaculate poster
Immaculate
2024 Β· dir. Michael Mohan
πŸ… 71%β˜… 5.7horror Β· mystery Β· thrillerNetflix

The same preoccupation in both: excited

The difference: 26 years apart, and the 2020s show

An American nun embarks on a new journey when she joins a remote convent in the Italian countryside. However, her warm welcome quickly turns into a living nightmare when she discovers her new home harbours a sinister secret and unspeakable horrors.

Finders Keepers poster
Finders Keepers
2014 Β· dir. Alexander Yellen
πŸ… 98%β˜… 4.3mystery Β· thriller Β· horrorPrime VideoPeacock

Both keep coming back to the same thing: murder

A haunted doll teaches one little girl why children shouldn't play with undead things.

Resolution poster
Resolution
2013 Β· dir. Justin Benson
πŸ… 81%β˜… 6.4horror Β· thriller Β· mysteryRent or buy

Both land unease and tension at once

A man imprisons his estranged junkie friend in an isolated cabin in the boonies of San Diego to force him through a week of sobriety, but the events of that week are being mysteriously manipulated.

Stonehearst Asylum poster
Stonehearst Asylum
2014 Β· dir. Brad Anderson
πŸ… 52%β˜… 6.8thriller Β· mystery Β· horrorPrime Video

Twisty mystery, and it commits to that

An Oxford Medical School graduate takes a position at a mental institution and soon becomes obsessed with a female mental patient, but he has no idea of a recent and horrifying staffing change.

House of Wax poster
House of Wax
2005 Β· dir. Jaume Collet-Serra
πŸ… 27%β˜… 5.5horror Β· thriller Β· mysteryPrime VideoMax

Both are working the same pair: slasher, killer

A group of unwitting teens are stranded near a strange wax museum and soon must fight to survive and keep from becoming the next exhibit.

Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers poster
Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers
1988 Β· dir. Dwight H. Little
πŸ… 42%β˜… 5.8horror Β· thriller

One thread runs through both: twist

Ten years after his original massacre, the invalid Michael Myers awakens on Halloween Eve and returns to Haddonfield to kill his seven-year-old niece.

Devil poster
Devil
2010 Β· dir. John Erick Dowdle
πŸ… 49%β˜… 6.3horror Β· mystery Β· thriller

Both are built on the same subject: suspense

A group of people are trapped in an elevator high above Philadelphia, and one of them is the Devil.

Ghost Ship poster
Ghost Ship
2002 Β· dir. Steve Beck
πŸ… 14%β˜… 5.6horror Β· mystery Β· thrillerPrime Video

Horror with a pulse of dread, in both cases

After discovering a passenger ship missing since 1962 floating adrift on the Bering Sea, salvagers claim the vessel as their own. Once they begin towing the ghost ship towards harbor, a series of bizarre occurrences happen and the group becomes trapped inside the ship, which they soon learn is inhabited by a demonic creature.

The Grudge poster
The Grudge
2004 Β· dir. Takashi Shimizu
πŸ… 41%β˜… 5.9horror Β· mystery Β· thrillerPeacock

Unsettling thriller in both cases

An American nurse living and working in Tokyo is exposed to a mysterious supernatural curse, one that locks a person in a powerful rage before claiming their life and spreading to another victim.

Silent Hill: Revelation 3D poster
Silent Hill: Revelation 3D
2012 Β· dir. MJ Bassett
πŸ… 8%β˜… 4.9thriller Β· horror Β· mysteryPrime Video

Mystery built on tension, twice over

Heather Mason and her father have been on the run, always one step ahead of dangerous forces that she doesn't fully understand. Now on the eve of her 18th birthday, plagued by horrific nightmares and the disappearance of her father, Heather discovers she's not who she thinks she is. The revelation leads her deeper into a demonic world that threatens to trap her forever.

The feel of Urban Legend, by the numbers

  • Twisty is one of its rarer notes: only 475 of the 4,931 films we track carry it (9.6%).
  • 12 of its 12 closest matches share its twisty streak, which is the thread tying this list together.

How common each of its moods is across everything we track (a full bar is 40% or more):

twisty9.6%
dread13.9%
tense26.9%

In the mood for more twisty?

all twisty movies β†’

The best-reviewed films that share Urban Legend’s defining feeling.