feelsalike.comSign in
Heretic poster

Movies that feel likeHeretic (2024)

Two young missionaries are forced to prove their faith when they knock on the wrong door and are greeted by a diabolical Mr. Reed, becoming ensnared in his deadly game of cat-and-mouse.

If you loved Heretic, the closest films we have are When Evil Lurks (2023), Don't Breathe (2016) and Orphan: First Kill (2022). All three share Heretic's tense and dread feel, which is what we rank on before quality.

Seen the big three already? The under-the-radar pick below is Unsane (2018).

🍅 89% Rotten Tomatoes★ 7 IMDb ↗TMDB ↗dir. Scott Becktensedreadunsettling
10 of 12 streaming nowNetflix · HBO Max · Hulu

Can't choose? Answer three questions and get one movie for tonight.

Stream it:Hulu ↗
Rent or buy:Amazon see price ↗Apple TV$3.99 rent · $12.99 buyApple price as of 2026-11-21
See it on the Mood Map

When is Heretic streaming? ↓

If Heretic hit the spot, these will too

When Evil Lurks poster
When Evil Lurks
2023 · dir. Demián Rugna
🍅 96%★ 6.9horror · thrillerRent or buy

The same mix in both: tension, then dread

When brothers Pedro and Jimi discover that a demonic infection has been festering in a nearby farmhouse, they attempt to evict the victim from their land. Failing to adhere to the proper rites of exorcism, their reckless actions inadvertently trigger an epidemic of possessions across their rural community.

Don't Breathe poster
Don't Breathe
2016 · dir. Fede Álvarez
🍅 88%★ 7.1horror · thrillerHulu

One thread runs through both: held captive

A group of teens break into a blind man's home thinking they'll get away with the perfect crime. They're wrong.

Orphan: First Kill poster
Orphan: First Kill
2022 · dir. William Brent Bell
🍅 69%★ 5.9horror · thrillerParamount+

Thriller built on unease, twice over

After escaping from an Estonian psychiatric facility, Leena Klammer travels to America by impersonating Esther, the missing daughter of a wealthy family. But when her mask starts to slip, she is put against a mother who will protect her family from the murderous “child” at any cost.

Unsane poster
Unsane
2018 · dir. Steven Soderbergh
🍅 80%★ 6.4horror · thriller

Tense horror, and it commits to that

A woman is involuntarily committed to a mental institution where she is confronted by her greatest fear.

Evil Dead Rise poster
Evil Dead Rise
2023 · dir. Lee Cronin
🍅 85%★ 6.5horror · thrillerMax

Thriller with a pulse of dread, in both cases

A reunion between two estranged sisters gets cut short by the rise of flesh-possessing demons, thrusting them into a primal battle for survival as they face the most nightmarish version of family imaginable.

Candyman poster
Candyman
2021 · dir. Nia DaCosta
🍅 83%★ 5.9horror · thrillerRent or buy

Both lean on unease more than on horror

A Chicago artist's sanity starts to unravel, unleashing a terrifying wave of violence when he begins to explore the macabre history of the Candyman.

Countdown poster
Countdown
2019 · dir. Justin Dec
🍅 26%★ 5.4horror · thrillerNetflix

Both keep coming back to the same thing: religion

The difference: The scrappier of the two with critics

A young nurse downloads an app that tells her she only has three days to live. With time ticking away and a mysterious figure haunting her, she must find a way to save her life before time runs out.

Death Whisperer poster
Death Whisperer
2023 · dir. Taweewat Wantha
★ 5.9horror · thrillerNetflix

Tense thriller in both cases

When a remote village is plagued by a deadly curse, one brother must fight to save his family from a terrifying supernatural threat.

Insidious: The Red Door poster
Insidious: The Red Door
2023 · dir. Patrick Wilson
🍅 40%★ 5.5horror · thrillerMaxHulu

Dread-soaked horror, and it commits to that

To put their demons to rest once and for all, Josh Lambert and a college-aged Dalton Lambert must go deeper into The Further than ever before, facing their family's dark past and a host of new and more horrifying terrors that lurk behind the red door.

Crawl poster
Crawl
2019 · dir. Alexandre Aja
🍅 84%★ 6.1horror · thrillerNetflixParamount+

A streak of unease through both

When a huge hurricane hits her hometown in Florida, Haley ignores evacuation orders to look for her father. After finding him badly wounded, both are trapped by the flood. With virtually no time to escape the storm, they discover that rising water levels are the least of their problems.

Creep poster
Creep
2014 · dir. Patrick Brice
🍅 92%★ 6.3horror · thrillerNetflix

Cut from the same thriller cloth

Looking for work, Aaron comes across a cryptic online ad: "$1,000 for the day. Filming service. Discretion is appreciated." Low on cash and full of naiveté, he decides to go for it. He drives to a cabin in a remote mountain town where he meets Josef, his cinematic subject for the day. Josef is sincere and the project seems heartfelt, so Aaron begins to film. But as the day goes on, it becomes clear that Josef is not who he says, and his intentions are not at all pure.

Halloween Ends poster
Halloween Ends
2022 · dir. David Gordon Green
🍅 40%★ 5horror · thrillerNetflix

Both play horror straight

Four years after the events of Halloween in 2018, Laurie has decided to liberate herself from fear and rage and embrace life. But when a young man is accused of killing a boy he was babysitting, it ignites a cascade of violence and terror that will force Laurie to finally confront the evil she can’t control, once and for all.

The feel of Heretic, by the numbers

  • 12 of its 12 closest matches share its tense streak, which is the thread tying this list together.

How common each of its moods is across everything we track (a full bar is 40% or more):

tense26.9%
dread13.9%

When is Heretic streaming?

CONFIRMED

Heretic is streaming now

Included with a subscription on Hulu, HBO Max (via Prime Video Channels), Cinemax (via Prime Video Channels), Cinemax Apple TV channel.

In theaters (US)November 8, 2024
Days in theaters before digital32 days
Digital release (rent/buy)December 10, 2024
Streaming onHulu, HBO Max (via Prime Video Channels), Cinemax (via Prime Video Channels), Cinemax Apple TV channel
Price when we first tracked it (September 10, 2026)Buy $12.99 · Rent $3.99
Current price on Apple TV (as of November 21, 2026)Buy $12.99 · Rent $3.99

Context: Across 104 films released since 2025, the median theater-to-digital window is 33 days. Since 2015 across our catalog: 46 days over 670 films. See the full data →

In the mood for more tense?

all tense movies →

The best-reviewed films that share Heretic’s defining feeling.