feelsalike.comSign in
Fantasy Island poster

Movies that feel likeFantasy Island (2020)

A group of contest winners arrive at an island hotel to live out their dreams, only to find themselves trapped in nightmare scenarios.

If you loved Fantasy Island, the closest films we have are Scream (2022), Good Manners (2018) and The Medium (2021). All three share Fantasy Island's dread and unsettling feel, which is what we rank on before quality.

Seen the big three already? The under-the-radar pick below is A Dark Song (2016).

🍅 9% Rotten Tomatoes★ 4.9 IMDb ↗TMDB ↗dir. Jeff Wadlowepicdreamlikedreadunsettlingtwisty
11 of 12 streaming nowHBO Max · Amazon Prime Video · Paramount Plus Premium

Can't choose? Answer three questions and get one movie for tonight.

See it on the Mood Map

When is Fantasy Island streaming? ↓

If Fantasy Island hit the spot, these will too

Scream poster
Scream
2022 · dir. Tyler Gillett
🍅 76%★ 6.3horror · mysteryParamount+

Both land dream logic and dread at once

The difference: Reviewed even better

Twenty-five years after a streak of brutal murders shocked the quiet town of Woodsboro, a new killer has donned the Ghostface mask and begins targeting a group of teenagers to resurrect secrets from the town’s deadly past.

Good Manners poster
Good Manners
2018 · dir. Marco Dutra
🍅 96%★ 6.7fantasy · horror · mystery

The same mix in both: unease, then twists

The difference: Takes it somewhere less epic than Fantasy Island does

Clara, a lonely nurse from the outskirts of São Paulo, is hired by mysterious and wealthy Ana as the nanny for her unborn child. The two women develop a strong bond, but soon Clara discovers a terrifying secret about the child.

The Medium poster
The Medium
2021 · dir. Banjong Pisanthanakun
🍅 83%★ 6.5horror · mysteryRent or buy

Common ground in both: supernatural and supernatural horror

The difference: Easier on the scale than Fantasy Island

A shaman's family learn that their goddess is supposedly controlling one of them. However, their lives take a frightening turn when they realise the goddess has nothing to do with the possession.

Wes Craven's New Nightmare poster
Wes Craven's New Nightmare
1994 · dir. Wes Craven
🍅 76%★ 6.4horror · mystery · fantasy

Common ground: supernatural

The difference: 26 years apart, and the 1990s show

A demonic force has chosen Freddy Krueger as its portal to the real world. Can Heather Langenkamp play the part of Nancy one last time and trap the evil trying to enter our world?

Malignant poster
Malignant
2021 · dir. James Wan
🍅 77%★ 6.2horror · mystery · actionRent or buy

Horror built on dream logic, twice over

The difference: Leans harder into action than Fantasy Island does

Madison is paralyzed by shocking visions of grisly murders, and her torment worsens as she discovers that these waking dreams are in fact terrifying realities with a mysterious tie to her past.

A Dark Song poster
A Dark Song
2016 · dir. Liam Gavin
🍅 91%★ 6.2horror · fantasy · mystery

Fantasy with a pulse of dread, in both cases

A determined young woman and a damaged occultist risk their lives and souls to perform a dangerous ritual that will grant them what they want.

The Watchers poster
The Watchers
2024 · dir. Ishana Night Shyamalan
🍅 32%★ 5.7fantasy · horror · mysteryMax

One thread runs through both: dark fantasy

A young artist gets stranded in an extensive, immaculate forest in western Ireland, where, after finding shelter, she becomes trapped alongside three strangers, stalked by mysterious creatures each night.

Truth or Dare poster
Truth or Dare
2018 · dir. Jeff Wadlow
🍅 16%★ 5.3thriller · horrorMax

The same hand behind both of them: Jeff Wadlow

The difference: Sits closer to thriller than Fantasy Island does

A harmless game of "Truth or Dare" among friends turns deadly when someone—or something—begins to punish those who tell a lie—or refuse the dare.

Forbidden Empire poster
Forbidden Empire
2014 · dir. Oleg Stepchenko
★ 5.2thriller · adventure · mysteryPrime Video

Both keep coming back to the same thing: dark fantasy

Early 18th century. Cartographer Jonathan Green undertakes a scientific voyage from Europe to the East. Having passed through Transylvania and crossed the Carpathian Mountains, he finds himself in a small village lost in impassible woods. Nothing but chance and heavy fog could bring him to this cursed place. People who live here do not resemble any other people which the traveler saw before that. The villagers, having dug a deep moat to fend themselves from the rest of the world, share a naive belief that they could save themselves from evil, failing to understand that evil has made its nest in their souls and is waiting for an opportunity to gush out upon the world.

Mirrors poster
Mirrors
2008 · dir. Alexandre Aja
🍅 15%★ 6.1horror · mysteryPrime Video

Unsettling mystery in both cases

An ex-cop and his family are the target of an evil force that is using mirrors as a gateway into their home.

Paranormal Activity 2 poster
Paranormal Activity 2
2010 · dir. Tod Williams
🍅 58%★ 5.7horror · mysteryParamount+Starz

Both are built on the same subject: supernatural horror

Just as Daniel and Kristi welcome a newborn baby into their home, a demonic presence begins terrorizing them, tearing apart their perfect world and turning it into an inescapable nightmare.

The Last Voyage of the Demeter poster
The Last Voyage of the Demeter
2023 · dir. André Øvredal
★ 6.1horror · fantasyPeacock

Both lean on dream logic more than on adventure

The crew of the merchant ship Demeter attempts to survive the ocean voyage from Carpathia to London as they are stalked each night by a merciless presence onboard the ship.

The feel of Fantasy Island, by the numbers

  • Twisty is one of its rarer notes: only 475 of the 4,931 films we track carry it (9.6%).
  • 12 of its 12 closest matches share its dread streak, which is the thread tying this list together.

How common each of its moods is across everything we track (a full bar is 40% or more):

epic24.2%
dread13.9%
twisty9.6%

When is Fantasy Island streaming?

CONFIRMED

Fantasy Island is streaming now

Included with a subscription on Hulu, FXNow; also on fuboTV, YouTube TV (live-TV bundle).

In theaters (US)February 27, 2020
Days in theaters before digital47 days
Digital release (rent/buy)April 14, 2020
Streaming onHulu, fuboTV, YouTube TV, FXNow

Context: Across 104 films released since 2025, the median theater-to-digital window is 33 days. Since 2015 across our catalog: 46 days over 670 films. See the full data →

In the mood for more epic?

all epic movies →

The best-reviewed films that share Fantasy Island’s defining feeling.