
Movies that feel likeFantasy Island (2020)
If you loved Fantasy Island, the closest films we have are Scream (2022), Good Manners (2018) and The Medium (2021). All three share Fantasy Island's dread and unsettling feel, which is what we rank on before quality.
Seen the big three already? The under-the-radar pick below is A Dark Song (2016).
Can't choose? Answer three questions and get one movie for tonight.
If Fantasy Island hit the spot, these will too

Both land dream logic and dread at once
The difference: Reviewed even better

The same mix in both: unease, then twists
The difference: Takes it somewhere less epic than Fantasy Island does

Common ground in both: supernatural and supernatural horror
The difference: Easier on the scale than Fantasy Island

Common ground: supernatural
The difference: 26 years apart, and the 1990s show

Horror built on dream logic, twice over
The difference: Leans harder into action than Fantasy Island does

Fantasy with a pulse of dread, in both cases

One thread runs through both: dark fantasy

The same hand behind both of them: Jeff Wadlow
The difference: Sits closer to thriller than Fantasy Island does

Both keep coming back to the same thing: dark fantasy

Unsettling mystery in both cases

Both are built on the same subject: supernatural horror

Both lean on dream logic more than on adventure
The feel of Fantasy Island, by the numbers
- Twisty is one of its rarer notes: only 475 of the 4,931 films we track carry it (9.6%).
- 12 of its 12 closest matches share its dread streak, which is the thread tying this list together.
How common each of its moods is across everything we track (a full bar is 40% or more):
When is Fantasy Island streaming?
Fantasy Island is streaming now
Included with a subscription on Hulu, FXNow; also on fuboTV, YouTube TV (live-TV bundle).
Context: Across 104 films released since 2025, the median theater-to-digital window is 33 days. Since 2015 across our catalog: 46 days over 670 films. See the full data →
In the mood for more epic?
all epic movies →The best-reviewed films that share Fantasy Island’s defining feeling.









